Curtain Call Theatre & Stage
SEP / OCT 2026 · Arts & Culture ← Back to BuffaloVibe
Curtain Call  ·  Theatre & Stage  ·  SEP / OCT 2026

The Curtain Rises on a Buffalo Fall

A run of Broadway musicals, two string-quartet recitals, a live-to-film orchestral screening, and a fall's worth of comedy headliners — the Buffalo stage calendar for September and October is stacked. Here is what belongs on your calendar, and where to see it.

Act I Musicals
Act II Drama & Plays
Act III Opera & Classical
Act IV Local Stage
Epilogue On the Boards
Act I

Musicals

GULP! The Gay Beach Musical at Compass Performing Arts Factory
Curtain Call 🎭
Compass Performing Arts Factory
Sep 11, 2026 → Sep 27, 2026
VenueCompass Performing Arts Factory DatesSep 11, 2026 → Sep 27, 2026 TicketsGet tickets → GenreMusicalComedy
GULP! The Gay Beach Musical

Buffalo United Artists stages the rarely-revived 1970s queer musical comedy, set on the beach at Coney Island on the anniversary of the Stonewall Riots — a Western New York premiere decades in the making.

VenueShea's Buffalo Theatre DatesSep 12, 2026 → Sep 19, 2026 TicketsGet tickets → GenreMusicalWorld Music
Buena Vista Social Club

The Tony-nominated musical built from the Grammy-winning Cuban ensemble's story and songbook comes to Shea's Buffalo Theatre for a week-long run — a stage show about music itself, and the friendships that outlast the spotlight.

1776: The Musical at Lancaster Opera House
Curtain Call 🎭
Lancaster Opera House
Sep 25, 2026 → Oct 11, 2026
VenueLancaster Opera House DatesSep 25, 2026 → Oct 11, 2026 TicketsGet tickets → GenreMusicalHistory
1776: The Musical

Lancaster Opera House presents the Tony Award-winning musical reimagining of America's founding — the messy, complicated, and surprisingly funny debates behind the Declaration of Independence.

Bat Boy: The Musical at Shea's Smith Theatre
Curtain Call 🎭
Shea's Smith Theatre
Oct 1, 2026 → Oct 18, 2026
VenueShea's Smith Theatre DatesOct 1, 2026 → Oct 18, 2026 TicketsGet tickets → GenreMusicalHorror-Comedy
Bat Boy: The Musical

A comedic horror-musical about a half-boy, half-bat creature discovered in a cave near Hope Falls, West Virginia — a cult favorite with a rock score and a full ensemble cast, staged at Shea's Smith Theatre.

Sweeney Todd at Shea's 710 Theatre
Curtain Call 🎭
Shea's 710 Theatre
Oct 22, 2026 → Oct 31, 2026
VenueShea's 710 Theatre DatesOct 22, 2026 → Oct 31, 2026 TicketsGet tickets → GenreMusicalThriller
Sweeney Todd

Sondheim's dark musical thriller about a vengeful barber and his pie-making landlady returns to Shea's 710 Theatre for a run through Halloween week.

Hell's Kitchen (Touring) at Shea's Buffalo Theatre
Curtain Call 🎭
Shea's Buffalo Theatre
Oct 27, 2026 → Oct 31, 2026
VenueShea's Buffalo Theatre DatesOct 27, 2026 → Oct 31, 2026 TicketsGet tickets → GenreMusicalR&B
Hell's Kitchen (Touring)

Alicia Keys' Tony-winning musical, set in a Manhattan high-rise and built on her own songbook, makes its touring stop at Shea's Buffalo Theatre.

Act II

Drama & Plays

Irish Classical Theatre Company
Irish Classical Theatre Company
Venue625 Main Street Buffalo, NY 14203
Phone(716) 853-4282

Buffalo's home for classical and contemporary Irish drama, staging the greatest works of dramatic literature at the highest level of craft. [Drama, Classical]

View Season →
Kavinoky Theatre
Kavinoky Theatre
Venue320 Porter Avenue Buffalo, NY 14201
Phone(716) 829-7668

Over 180 shows in 37 years and more awards than any other theatre in Buffalo — the Kavinoky's subscriber base of 2,500 is proof the formula still works. [Drama]

View Season →
Road Less Traveled Theater
Road Less Traveled Theater
Venue500 Pearl Street Buffalo, NY 14202
Phone(716) 629-3069

An intimate 96-seat house in downtown Buffalo's Historical Theater District, built around innovative, provocative new work. [Drama, New Works]

View Season →
MusicalFare Theatre
MusicalFare Theatre
Venue4380 Main Street Amherst, NY 14226
Phone(716) 839-8540

A not-for-profit professional musical theatre company in Amherst dedicated to bringing quality musical theatre to Western New York. [Drama, Musical Theatre]

View Season →
Alleyway Theater
Alleyway Theater
Venue1 Curtain Up Alley Buffalo, NY 14202
Phone(716) 573-2704

Buffalo's alternative professional company, dedicated to new and innovative plays and musicals in a comfortable, intimate space. [Drama, New Works]

View Season →
Ujima Company, Inc. Theatre
Ujima Company, Inc. Theatre
Venue429 Plymouth Avenue Buffalo, NY 14213
Phone(716) 883-4232

For more than three decades, Ujima has built its reputation on reliability and a consistent artistic vision rooted in the Swahili principles for which it's named. [Drama]

View Season →
Act III

Opera & Classical

Slee Beethoven String Quartet Cycle: Borromeo Quartet at University at Buffalo - Slee Hall - Lippes Concert Hall
Curtain Call 🎭
University at Buffalo - Slee Hall - Lippes Concert Hall
Sep 24, 2026
VenueUniversity at Buffalo - Slee Hall - Lippes Concert Hall DatesSep 24, 2026 TicketsGet tickets → GenreChamber MusicClassical
Slee Beethoven String Quartet Cycle: Borromeo Quartet

The Borromeo Quartet continues UB's season-long cycle through the complete Beethoven string quartets, performing at Slee Hall's Lippes Concert Hall.

VenueUniversity at Buffalo - Slee Hall - Lippes Concert Hall DatesOct 10, 2026 TicketsGet tickets → GenreChamber MusicClassical
Jupiter String Quartet

The acclaimed Jupiter String Quartet returns to Lippes Concert Hall for an evening of chamber repertoire.

Ghostbusters In Concert at UB Center for the Arts - Mainstage Theatre
Curtain Call 🎭
UB Center for the Arts - Mainstage Theatre
Oct 16, 2026
VenueUB Center for the Arts - Mainstage Theatre DatesOct 16, 2026 TicketsGet tickets → GenreLive ScoreOrchestral
Ghostbusters In Concert

A live orchestra performs Elmer Bernstein's score alongside a full screening of Ghostbusters at UB's Mainstage Theatre — one of the strongest entries on Buffalo's growing live-to-film concert calendar.

Act IV

Local Stage

Helium Comedy Club
Helium Comedy Club
Venue30 Mississippi Street Buffalo, NY 14203
Phone(716) 853-1211

A state-of-the-art room bringing national headliners within 60 feet of the crowd — Buffalo's home stage for most of this issue's stand-up dates. [Comedy]

See What's Upcoming →
Buffalo ComedySportz Arena
Buffalo ComedySportz Arena
Venue4476 Main Street Amherst, NY 14226
Phone(716) 393-8669

Improv comedy played as a sport: two teams of comedians compete for points from the crowd while a referee calls fouls. [Comedy, Improv]

See What's Upcoming →
Rob's Comedy Playhouse
Rob's Comedy Playhouse
Venue1340 N Forest Rd Buffalo, NY 14221
Phone(716) 688-1867

A Williamsville comedy room built for a night out without a trip downtown. [Comedy]

See What's Upcoming →
The Murder Mystery Company
The Murder Mystery Company
VenueBuffalo, NY 14202
Phone(888) 643-2583

An interactive dinner-theatre whodunit, staged live and public or booked private — equal parts performance and party. [Comedy, Mystery]

See What's Upcoming →
Shea's Performing Arts Center
Shea's Performing Arts Center
Venue646 Main Street Buffalo, NY 14202
Phone(716) 847-1410

Built in the style of a European opera house in 1926 and now a National Historic Site, Shea's remains Buffalo's main presenting stage for touring Broadway, concerts, and dance.

See What's Upcoming →
Epilogue

On the Boards

Stand-up sets, one-off plays, and a modern-dress Macbeth — the acts and shows worth flagging now, before the good seats at the comedy clubs and the small houses disappear.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Curtain Call?
Curtain Call is our bi-monthly roundup of the Buffalo theatre and stage scene, organized into five acts: Musicals, Opera & Classical, Drama & Plays, Local Stage, and On the Boards. Each issue covers what's currently running or opening soon — touring Broadway shows at Shea's, community and professional drama companies, comedy clubs, and one-off performances worth flagging before tickets disappear.
Where do touring Broadway musicals play in Buffalo?
Shea's Performing Arts Center is Buffalo's main presenting venue for touring Broadway — a 1926 building styled after a European opera house and now a National Historic Site. It operates several stages under one roof, including Shea's Buffalo Theatre for the biggest touring productions, plus the smaller Shea's 710 Theatre and Shea's Smith Theatre for mid-size runs. Most of the national tours in each Curtain Call issue play one of these three rooms.
What's the difference between the Musicals, Drama & Plays, and Local Stage sections?
Musicals and Opera & Classical cover individual shows and performances — a specific production with a run of dates, whether it's a touring musical or a chamber recital. Drama & Plays and Local Stage instead spotlight companies and venues rather than single shows: dramatic theatre companies like Kavinoky Theatre and Irish Classical Theatre Company in Drama & Plays, and comedy clubs, improv houses, and dinner theatre like Helium Comedy Club or The Murder Mystery Company in Local Stage. On the Boards closes each issue with a mixed, dated look-ahead list.
Where can I see classical or orchestral music in Buffalo?
The University at Buffalo's Slee Hall — home to the Lippes Concert Hall — runs a chamber music series featuring touring string quartets, alongside UB's own recital programming. For orchestral programming, the Buffalo Philharmonic Orchestra performs at Kleinhans Music Hall, a landmark concert hall designed by Eliel and Eero Saarinen. Live-to-film orchestral concerts, where a live ensemble performs a film score alongside a full screening, also show up periodically at UB's Center for the Arts.
Where's the best place to catch stand-up comedy in Buffalo?
Helium Comedy Club is Buffalo's main national-headliner room — an intimate, state-of-the-art venue where no seat is more than 60 feet from the stage. For improv instead of stand-up, Buffalo ComedySportz Arena in Amherst runs a competitive, audience-judged format where two teams of comedians face off. Rob's Comedy Playhouse in Williamsville is a smaller neighborhood option for a night out without heading downtown.
Are there smaller, community dramatic theatre companies worth seeing?
Yes — Buffalo has an unusually deep bench of small and mid-size dramatic companies. Irish Classical Theatre Company focuses on Irish and international classics; Kavinoky Theatre has staged over 180 shows in 37 years with one of the city's largest subscriber bases; Road Less Traveled Theater is a 96-seat house built around innovative new work in the Historical Theater District; Alleyway Theater and Ujima Company, Inc. Theatre round out the scene with new plays and work rooted in Ujima's Swahili-named founding principles.
Get Curtain Call in your inbox

Openings, reviews & what to see next — delivered regularly.